• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Little Milly's Oven Fresh Pizza - Delicious and Affordable Pizzas in Youngstown, OH

At Little Milly's Oven Fresh Pizza, we believe in the craft of delivering exceptional pizza that warms the heart. Founded in the vibrant community of Youngstown, OH, we take pride in serving our customers an array of delicious, oven-fresh pizzas, subs, and specialty dishes, all at great value. Whether you’re indulging in our Meat Lover Deluxe or savoring the fresh Veggie Deluxe, each bite bursts with flavor. Our commitment to quality shines through, ensuring every pizza is made with care. With convenient delivery and takeout options, we invite you to experience comfort food redefined. Welcome to our story at Little Milly's!

Little Milly's Oven Fresh Pizza at a glance

  • Address 2608 South Ave Youngstown, OH 44502 United States
  • Phone (330) 788-2330
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner .

Photos & Gallery

Little Milly's Oven Fresh Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Sue DeGan
5

The pizza here is Delicious! A great staple to the Youngstown area! I ordered the vegetable and pineapple pizza, and my family devoured both! Pepperoni rolls are fantastic! Little Milly's is where you want to go if you love really good, authentic pizza! Thanks for the love you put in your food

Jared Zapalac
5

Really tasty, yet super cheap pizza is available here!!!!!!! Its pretty dang good, and 5 bucks for this whole pizza is a deal you just can't beat. Its definitely not the highest quality pizza, but for 5 dollars you honestly cannot complain. The service was really quick and speedy, definitely a great pizza shop!!!!

Expo Z
5

I love there food and it's cheap and the works there are so sweet

Klou DaTruph
5

This place is a divine anomaly! Every single ingredient has its unique taste reserved only for here. Granted, I do have to order my pizza to my particular tastes. As I do anywhere else. But when Little Millys gets it right (as they normally do) it's like the Pizza God's aligned the stars! No longer are the days Belleria/Wedgewood reign. And the prices are good...not great, but I'll never complain over a great pie!

Carmen MottaGuedes
5

I previously visited Little Millys Oven Fresh Pizza,I had ordered 2 Large Pepperoni rolls and they were absolutely delicious I can't wait to go back and get another Pepperoni Roll.

Stephanie Whitmore
5

Great friendly service, the pepperoni rolls and Stromboli is to die for! Plus it’s super inexpensive. Great quality!

Robert Littrell
5

This place has been a staple in our community for a long time and honestly I don't know how they've stayed in business by keeping their prices so small and paying their employees as well as taking care of the daycare across the street.. just an awesome business all around..

Regina Marker
5

The best and most affordable food in the Ohio Valley! Cinnamon "rolls" for .50 cents, meal worthy bread sticks $1.50, delicious pepperoni rolls for $3 and then there's the pizza! You can eat lunch everyday, not break the bank and enough options to never get burned out! If that's not enough, the people are great too!

Location

  • Little Milly's Oven Fresh Pizza
    Little Milly's Oven Fresh Pizza
    2608 South Ave Youngstown, OH 44502 United States Hotline: (330) 788-2330

Welcome to the delicious world of Little Milly's Oven Fresh Pizza, a hidden gem located at 2608 South Ave, Youngstown, OH. This unclaimed pizza parlor has been delighting taste buds for years, earning a loyal following for its fresh, oven-baked pies and scrumptious subs. Offering both delivery and takeout, Little Milly's is perfect for those cozy nights in or impromptu pizza parties.

What sets Little Milly's apart is not just its affordability but the superb quality of its ingredients. Their Famous Oven Fresh Pizza comes in various sizes, whether you're after a personal 12" or need enough to feed a crowd with a generous 16" tray pizza. Starting at just $8.99 for the classic cheese, you’d be hard-pressed to find better value in the area.

  • Specialty Pizzas: For those craving something unique, their specialty pizzas like the Buffalo Chicken with Ranch Sauce and Hawaiian promise to please with bold flavors and fresh toppings—all priced around $12.99.
  • Subs: Don't miss out on the subs, where favorites like the Meatball Sub and the indulgent Xtreme Sub (a flavor explosion of all ingredients combined) are all available for just $10.99.

Customer reviews speak volumes about the quality that Little Milly’s delivers. One delighted diner, E.M., notes, “I mess with this pizza,” highlighting not only the taste but also the convenience of services like DoorDash. Meanwhile, Simone U. elaborates, “Don’t let the low prices fool you… this is fresh hot pizza that I would compare to any high-end pizza place.”

Little Milly's is not just another pizza shop; it's a celebration of comfort food crafted with passion and dedication. So, whether you’re in the mood for classic cheese or adventurous toppings, make your way to Little Milly's Oven Fresh Pizza and treat yourself to a slice of happiness. Happy eating!

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway